From: Holly Wild email0: NY Times Category: Birth Injury Date: 19 Nov 2008 Time: 23:11:12 -0500
A jury has ordered the Health and Hospitals Corporation to pay $76.4 million
to a 12-year-old girl who suffered brain damage and other permanent injuries
during her birth in what her lawyer called a botched delivery at Harlem Hospital
Center. It was one of the largest malpractice verdicts ever recorded against the
corporation, which runs the city's hospitals.
The award, returned last Friday by a State Supreme Court jury in Manhattan, was
made to a girl, who was born on Jan. 16, 1987. She was born with her umbilical
cord wrapped around her neck and with no medical personnel in the hospital room
to attend her mother who underwent 17 hours of labor.
Given that the infant was already severely compromised for 17 hours, and was
strangled by her own umbilical cord and was not breathing, every second was
crucial. There was no one on hand to administer immediate resuscitation and
live-saving measures. This was a classic example of the indifferent and
horrendous care that the city's H.H.C. has been chastised for.
The chief counsel to the hospitals corporation, denied that there had been
anything improper in the delivery and insisted that the hospital care had been
''excellent.'' He said the city would move to have the verdict set aside as
''grossly excessive'' and, failing that, would appeal.
The verdict was one of the largest ever delivered against the city in a medical
malpractice case. A jury in Queens last year awarded more than $112 million in
an obstetrics case, but a later settlement reduced the sum to $4.5 million. A
Manhattan jury awarded $49 million last year in an obstetrics case against Lenox
Hill Hospital, and a Bronx jury in 1995 ordered the Health and Hospitals
Corporation to pay $42 million to the mother of a girl injured at birth at
The infant, whose mother is a housewife and whose father, Sensois, has worked as
a kitchen helper and a janitor to pay for her medical care, suffers from
cerebral palsy, requires a wheelchair and round-the-clock care and is unable to
read or write. The family -- there are five other children -- lives in lower
The family's lawyer, Mr. Moore, said the verdict, returned by a jury of three
men and three women after a two-week trial and two hours of deliberations,
included $35 million for future medical care and loss of earning capacity, $5
million for past suffering and $36.4 million for future suffering. He said the
city had turned down a settlement offer of $3.5 million just before the trial.
The mother a Haitian immigrant, was admitted to Harlem Hospital at 9 A.M. on
Jan. 15, 1987, and that a staff of ''unsupervised, inexperienced and overworked
obstetrical residents'' allowed labor to continue for 17 hours and failed to
detect that the umbilical cord was a threat to the unborn child.
She was never evaluated by an attending physician. In addition, fetal heart
monitor tapes and other records were either missing or altered, and a critical
test -- which would have shown that the umbilical cord was wrapped around the
infant's neck, causing a decelerated heart rate -- had been ordered, but the
residents forgot to administer it.''
The mother eventually delivered the baby with no one else in the room -- ''no
doctor, no nurse, no one, left the child to be born with the cord ''wrapped
tightly around her neck, not breathing, and requiring immediate resuscitation.''
During labor the residents had administered the drug Pitocin, which stimulated
forceful contractions. But, he said, ''instead of rescuing the infant from the
womb through emergency Caesarean section, they exacerbated the problem and
allowed the umbilical cord to act as a noose.''